-
Expand entry
-
Added by: Jamie Collin, Contributed by:
Summary: Thomasson argues that merely verbal disputes arise in metaphysics when ontologists misuse the words ‘thing’ and ‘object’. Application conditions fix the conditions under which a claim can be applied or refused, but some ontological disputes involve using the terms ‘thing’ and ‘object’ in such a way that they lack application conditions. When this happens there is no way to determine the truth values of the claims being made.
Comment: This would be useful in a course on metaphysics, ontology or metametaphysics. It gives an interesting and plausible articulation of the idea that some metaphysical disputes are illegitimate in some sense (an intution that some students share). This isn't an easy paper, but it is clearly written and suitable for advanced undergraduates or graduates.
Thomasson, Amie. Answerable and Unanswerable Questions
2009, In MetaMetaphysics, eds. David Chalmers, Ryan Wasserman, and David Manley. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 444-471.
Can't find it?
Contribute the texts you think should be here and we'll add them soon!
Categories
- Value Theory (379)
- Aesthetics (111)
- Aesthetic cognition (5)
- Aesthetic Taste (1)
- Aesthetic Criticism (2)
- Aesthetic Experience (5)
- Aesthetic Imagination (6)
- Aesthetic Interpretation (6)
- Aesthetic Judgment (2)
- Aesthetic Pleasure (3)
- Aesthetic Qualities (4)
- Beauty (3)
- Aesthetic Representation (22)
- Aesthetic Universality (1)
- Aesthetic Value (5)
- Aesthetics (1)
- Aesthetics and Culture (7)
- Aesthetics and Emotions (3)
- Aesthetics of Nature (2)
- Art and Artworks (30)
- Definition of Art (13)
- non-Western art (2)
- The Value of Art (2)
- Body Aesthetics (6)
- Crosscultural Aesthetics (1)
- Fictional Characters (1)
- Food and Drink (1)
- Aesthetics, General Works (1)
- Literary imagination (1)
- Literature and Emotion (4)
- Music and Emotion (1)
- Narrative (1)
- Ontology of art (2)
- Painting and Drawing (4)
- Philosophy of Literature (10)
- Fiction (6)
- Philosophy of Music (2)
- Philosophy of Theatre (1)
- Philosophy of Visual Art (2)
- Photography (5)
- The Value of Art (1)
- Aesthetic cognition (5)
- Applied Ethics (130)
- Abortion (10)
- Animal Ethics (3)
- Animal Rights (2)
- Assisted Suicide (2)
- Autonomy (13)
- Bioethics (2)
- Biomedical Ethics (14)
- Business Ethics (6)
- Organisational Ethics (1)
- Whistleblowing (1)
- Organisational Ethics (1)
- Cognitive Enhancement (1)
- Contraception (1)
- Deception (3)
- Disability (9)
- Environmental Ethics (9)
- Euthanasia (4)
- Family Ethics (2)
- Financial Ethics (1)
- Genetic Testing (1)
- Global Justice (7)
- Harm (1)
- Health Care Justice (1)
- Human Genetic Modification (1)
- Imprisonment (1)
- Informed Consent in Medicine (1)
- International Ethics (1)
- Medical Ethics (12)
- Biomedical Ethics (1)
- Psychiatric Ethics (2)
- Military Ethics (6)
- post ad bellum (1)
- Theory of self defense (1)
- Morality of Procreation (3)
- Neuroethics (3)
- Parenthood (2)
- Paternalism (2)
- Political Ethics (6)
- Professional Ethics (3)
- Punishment (1)
- Reproductive Ethics (3)
- Responsibility in Applied Ethics (1)
- Social Ethics (1)
- Speciesism (1)
- Sport (2)
- Toleration (1)
- Vegetarianism (2)
- Metaethics (16)
- Amoralists (1)
- Collective Responsibility (1)
- Control and Responsibility (1)
- Cornell Realism (1)
- Internalism and Externalism about Moral Judgment (1)
- Moral Constructivism (1)
- Moral Expressivism (2)
- Moral Irrealism (1)
- Moral Motivation (1)
- Moral Naturalism (2)
- Moral Noncognitivism (1)
- Moral Nonnaturalism (1)
- Moral Rationality (1)
- Moral Realism (1)
- Moral Relativism (2)
- Ought Implies Can (1)
- Practical Reason (1)
- Miscellaneous (13)
- Ethics (7)
- Ethics and Religion (1)
- Incommensurability of Value (1)
- Meaning of Life (1)
- Normativity (1)
- Varieties of Value (1)
- Normative Ethics (67)
- Anger (1)
- Anti-Theory (1)
- Buck-Passing Accounts of Moral Value (1)
- Consequentialism (1)
- Utilitarianism (1)
- Deontological Moral Theories (3)
- Kantian Ethics (3)
- Disgust (2)
- Empathy and Sympathy (1)
- Ethics and Cognitive Science (1)
- Ethics of Care (1)
- Evolution of Morality (1)
- Feminist Ethics (10)
- Guilt and Shame (1)
- Hope (4)
- Integrity (1)
- Manners (1)
- Moral Character (4)
- Moral Contractualism (3)
- Moral Luck (1)
- Moral Psychology (2)
- Moral Sainthood (1)
- Moral Worth (1)
- Objections to Consequentialism (1)
- Objections to Utilitarianism (1)
- Objections to Virtue Ethics (3)
- Promises (2)
- Religious Ethics (1)
- Skepticism about Character (1)
- Supererogation (1)
- The Doctrine of Double Effect (4)
- The Good (1)
- The Good Will and Moral Worth (1)
- The Trolley Problem (2)
- Theories of Moral Value (1)
- Topics in Consequentialism (1)
- Topics in Virtue Ethics (7)
- Trust (3)
- Value Pluralism (1)
- Varieties of Virtue Ethics (2)
- Virtue Ethics (11)
- Virtue Ethics and Eudaimonia (1)
- Virtue Ethics and Practical Wisdom (1)
- Virtues and Vices (3)
- Philosophy of Gender, Race, and Sexuality (82)
- Analytic Feminism (1)
- Ecofeminism (1)
- Feminism: Disability (4)
- Feminism: Global Justice (1)
- Feminism: Marriage and Civil Unions (2)
- Feminism: Rape and Sexual Violence (3)
- Feminism: Reproduction (1)
- Feminism: The Body (1)
- Feminist Aesthetics (7)
- Feminist History of Philosophy (1)
- Feminist Metaphysics (7)
- Feminist Philosophy (5)
- Feminist Philosophy of Religion (5)
- Feminist Philosophy of Science (1)
- Feminist Political Philosophy (3)
- Gay Marriage (2)
- History: Feminist Philosophy (5)
- Homosexuality, Politics and the Law (1)
- Philosophy of Gender (7)
- Philosophy of Love (2)
- Philosophy of Race (10)
- Aesthetics and Race (2)
- Cosmopolitanism (2)
- Intersectionality (1)
- Racism and Psychology (1)
- Philosophy of Sexuality (2)
- Pornography (4)
- Queer Theory (2)
- Racial Identity (2)
- Racial Inequality (1)
- Racism (2)
- Relationships and Marriage (2)
- Sexual Objectification (1)
- The Sex/Gender Distinction (1)
- Topics in Feminist Philosophy (1)
- Philosophy of Law (8)
- Social and Political Philosophy (92)
- Activism (1)
- Autonomy in Political Theories (1)
- Autonomy (6)
- Contractualism about Political Authority (2)
- Cosmopolitanism (2)
- Culture and Cultures (1)
- Disability Rights (1)
- Distributive Justice (1)
- Egalitarianism (2)
- Environmental Rights (1)
- Equality (3)
- Equality and Responsibility (3)
- Equality of Welfare (1)
- Ethics and Justification of War (1)
- Freedom and Liberty (2)
- Oppression (1)
- Dehumanization (1)
- Oppression (1)
- Global Governance (2)
- Global Justice (1)
- Human Rights (1)
- Immigration (1)
- Immigration Rights (1)
- Implicit Bias (3)
- International Justice (2)
- Just War Theory (2)
- Justice (7)
- Methods in Political Philosophy (1)
- Minority Rights (1)
- Moral Cosmopolitanism (1)
- Nationalism (1)
- Nature of War (1)
- Pacifism (1)
- Patriotism (2)
- Political Cosmopolitanism (1)
- Political Feasibility (1)
- Political Power (1)
- Political Theory (7)
- Property Rights (7)
- Purpose of War (1)
- Rape (3)
- Rights (2)
- Rights and Poverty (1)
- Rights of Future Generations (1)
- Rights to Reparations (1)
- Terrorism (2)
- Toleration (2)
- Toleration in Normative Theories (3)
- War and Violence (3)
- Torture (1)
- Aesthetics (111)
- Metaphysics & Epistemology (299)
- Epistemology (79)
- Content Externalist Replies to Skepticism (1)
- Critical Thinking (1)
- Deductive Reasoning (1)
- Defining Knowledge (1)
- Dogmatist and Moorean Replies to Skepticism (1)
- Doxastic Voluntarism (1)
- Entitlement (1)
- Epistemic Contextualism and Invariantism (7)
- Epistemic Injustice (4)
- Epistemic Internalism and Externalism (1)
- Epistemic Normativity (2)
- Epistemic Norms (2)
- Epistemic Possibility (1)
- Epistemic Relativism (1)
- Epistemic Responsibility (1)
- Epistemic Value (5)
- Epistemic Virtue (3)
- Epistemological States and Properties (3)
- Justification (1)
- Rationality (1)
- Epistemology, General Works (1)
- Epistemology of Intuition (5)
- Epistemology of Specific Domains (1)
- Epistemology of Testimony (7)
- Ethics of Belief (3)
- Evidence (1)
- Evidence and Knowledge (3)
- Feminist Epistemology (7)
- Formal Epistemology (2)
- Formal Social Epistemology (1)
- Foundationalism and Coherentism (2)
- History: Skepticism (1)
- Ignorance (1)
- Justification (1)
- Knowledge by Acquaintance (1)
- Luminosity (1)
- Metaepistemology (1)
- Naturalized Epistemology (2)
- Ordinary Language Replies to Skepticism (1)
- Pragmatic Encroachment (5)
- Primitivism about Knowledge (2)
- Rationality (3)
- Reliabilism about Knowledge (1)
- Social Epistemology (5)
- The A Priori (1)
- The Concept of Knowledge (1)
- The Gettier Problem (2)
- The Nature of Intuition (5)
- Transmission of Warrant (2)
- Understanding (1)
- Virtue Epistemology (11)
- Wisdom (1)
- Metaphilosophy (18)
- Critiques of Experimental Philosophy (1)
- Empiricism (1)
- Epistemology of Philosophy (1)
- Experimental Philosophy (8)
- Formal Philosophy (1)
- Naturalism (2)
- Philosophical Methods (1)
- Pragmatism (1)
- Thought Experiments (5)
- Metaphysics (71)
- Abstract Objects (1)
- Actualism (1)
- Anti-Realism about Laws (1)
- Artifacts (1)
- Best-Systems Analyses (2)
- Causal Eliminativism (1)
- Causal Realism (1)
- Causal Reductionism (1)
- Causal Relata (1)
- Causation (2)
- Ceteris Paribus Laws (2)
- Conceivability, Imagination, and Possibility (1)
- Concepts of Emergence (1)
- Conditional Analyses (1)
- Dispositional and Categorical Properties (1)
- Dispositions and Laws (3)
- Dispositions and Powers (1)
- Downward Causation (1)
- Essentialism (1)
- Essentialism and De Re Modality (1)
- Eternalism (1)
- Fission and Split Brains (1)
- Metaphysics, General Works (2)
- Humeanism and Nonhumeanism about Laws (4)
- Idealism (1)
- Laws of Nature (2)
- Material Objects (3)
- McTaggart's Argument (1)
- Metaontology (1)
- Metaphysical Necessity (3)
- Metaphysics (1)
- Methodology in Metaphysics (3)
- Modal Realism (1)
- Narrative Identity (1)
- Objects (3)
- Ontological Realism (1)
- Ontology (5)
- Perdurance (1)
- Persistence (3)
- Personal Identity (2)
- Philosophy of Time (2)
- Physical and Animalist Theories Of Personal Identity (1)
- Powers (1)
- Practical Identity (1)
- Problem of the Many (1)
- Properties (2)
- Psychological Theories of Personal Identity (1)
- Simples and Gunk (1)
- Supervenience (1)
- The Body (1)
- The Direction of Time (1)
- Theories of Causation (2)
- Theories of Modality (1)
- Time (6)
- Temporal Ontology (4)
- Presentism (1)
- The Open Future (4)
- Temporal Ontology (4)
- Time Travel (3)
- Varieties of Causation (1)
- Philosophy of Mind (77)
- Aspects of Consciousness (2)
- Consciousness and Content (1)
- Consciousness and Materialism (2)
- Consciousness of Action (1)
- Content Internalism and Externalism (3)
- Creativity (1)
- Disjunctivism (1)
- Dualism (4)
- Eliminativism about Propositional Attitudes (1)
- Eliminativism about Qualia (1)
- Emotions (4)
- Epistemology of Mind (2)
- Experience of Temporal Passage (1)
- Expression-Based Accounts of Self-Knowledge (1)
- Externalism and Armchair Knowledge (2)
- Externalism and Slow Switching (1)
- First-Person Contents (1)
- Imagination and Pretense (3)
- Imaginative Resistance (5)
- Inferentialist Accounts of Meaning and Content (1)
- Information-Based Accounts of Mental Content (1)
- Knowledge of Consciousness (1)
- Mental Actions (1)
- Mental Causation (1)
- Mental States (3)
- Mental States and Processes (10)
- Imagination (9)
- Mental Imagery (3)
- Metaphysics of Mind (3)
- Naive and Direct Realism (2)
- Narrow Content (1)
- Nonreductive Materialism (1)
- Observation-Based Accounts of Self-Knowledge (1)
- Panpsychism (1)
- Perception (4)
- Perceptual Knowledge (1)
- The Given (1)
- Perceptual Knowledge (1)
- Perception and Action (1)
- Perception and Skepticism (1)
- Perceptual Justification (1)
- Perceptual Particularity (1)
- Phenomenal Concepts (1)
- Philosophy of Consciousness (1)
- Philosophy of Mind, General Works (2)
- Physicalism (5)
- Psychophysical Emergence (1)
- Rationality-Based Accounts of Self-Knowledge (1)
- Self-Knowledge (2)
- Sense-Datum Theories (1)
- Social Externalism (1)
- Teleological Accounts of Mental Content (2)
- The Exclusion Problem (1)
- The Extended Mind (1)
- The Nature of Belief (3)
- Twin Earth and Externalism (1)
- What is it Like? (1)
- Zombies and the Conceivability Argument (1)
- Philosophy of Action (30)
- Action Theory (3)
- Causal Theory of Action (2)
- Collective Action (1)
- Compatibilism (2)
- Decision-Theoretic Frameworks (1)
- Defining Action (1)
- Deliberation (2)
- Explanation of Action (3)
- Free Will (8)
- Agent Causation (1)
- Determinism (2)
- Libertarianism about Free Will (1)
- Free Will and Neuroscience (1)
- Free Will and Responsibility (1)
- Instrumental Reasoning (1)
- Intentional Action (2)
- Motivation (1)
- Noncausal Theories of Action (1)
- Normative and Descriptive Decision Theory (1)
- Practical and Theoretical Reasoning (2)
- Practical Reason (1)
- Preferences in Decision Theory (1)
- Reasons (4)
- Reasons and Causes (2)
- Subjective and Objective Reasons (1)
- The Nature of Action (4)
- The Will (1)
- Theories of Free Will (1)
- Utility (1)
- Philosophy of Language (44)
- Accomplishments (1)
- Achievements (1)
- Activities (1)
- Descriptions (1)
- Desire Ascriptions (2)
- Feminist Philosophy of Language (4)
- Generics (1)
- Indexicals and Demonstratives (1)
- Linguistic Communication (1)
- Meaning (4)
- Metaphor (1)
- Minimalism and Deflationism about Truth (3)
- Modal Expressions (1)
- Norms of Assertion (2)
- Philosophy of Language, General Works (1)
- Philosophy of Linguistics (2)
- Pragmatics (2)
- Pragmatism about Truth (2)
- Prosentential Theory of Truth (1)
- Reference (2)
- Relevance Theory (1)
- Russellian and Direct Reference Theories (1)
- Scope (1)
- Sorites Paradox (1)
- Specific Expressions (1)
- Speech Acts (3)
- States (1)
- Subjunctive Conditionals (1)
- Supervaluationism (1)
- The Analytic-Synthetic Distinction (2)
- Truth (8)
- Vagueness and Indeterminacy (2)
- Verificationist Theories of Meaning (1)
- Philosophy of Religion (44)
- Afterlife (2)
- Agnosticism (2)
- Arguments Against Theism (8)
- Arguments for Theism (7)
- Atheism (4)
- Comparative Philosophy of Religion (1)
- Divine Attributes (7)
- Divine Eternity (1)
- Divine Omniscience (2)
- Divine Passibility (1)
- Divine Simplicity (1)
- Epistemology of Religion (4)
- Evil (2)
- Faith (4)
- Fictionalism (3)
- Heaven and Hell (1)
- Prayer (2)
- Religious Diversity (1)
- Sin (1)
- Specific Religions (6)
- Buddhism (1)
- Christianity (4)
- The Trinity (1)
- Islam (1)
- The Soul (1)
- Epistemology (79)
- . (6)
- Science, Logic & Mathematics (168)
- General Philosophy of Science (61)
- Abduction and Scientific Realism (1)
- Analogy in Science (4)
- Arguments For and Against Scientific Realism (3)
- Confirmation (1)
- Confirmation Holism (1)
- Constructive Empiricism (1)
- Empirically Equivalent Theories (1)
- Experimentation in Science (2)
- Explanation (1)
- Explanation and Laws (1)
- Explanatory Value (2)
- Feminist Philosophy of Science (1)
- History of Science (2)
- Idealisation (1)
- Induction (1)
- Interlevel Relations in Science (1)
- Laws of Nature (4)
- Models (8)
- Multiple Realizability (1)
- Necessitarianism about Laws (1)
- Nonempirical Virtues (1)
- Philosophy of Science, General Works (4)
- Reductionism (3)
- Science and Values (6)
- Scientific Change (1)
- Scientific Conventionalism (1)
- Scientific Discovery (1)
- Scientific Fictionalism (1)
- Scientific Instruments (1)
- Scientific Method (4)
- Scientific Practice (4)
- Scientific Representation (1)
- Sociology of Science (2)
- Structural Realism (2)
- The Observation-Theory Distinction (1)
- Theoretical Virtues (1)
- Underdetermination of Theory by Data (4)
- Unification Accounts of Explanation (2)
- Unity of Science (1)
- Varieties of Scientific Realism (2)
- Logic and Philosophy of Logic (26)
- Fuzzy Logic (2)
- Logic, General Works (3)
- Informal Logic (1)
- Introductions to Logic (4)
- Liar Paradox (5)
- Logic (1)
- Logical Consequence and Entailment (3)
- Logical Pluralism (1)
- Model Theory (1)
- Predicate Logic (1)
- Proof Theory (1)
- Temporal Logic (1)
- Vagueness (1)
- Philosophy of Biology (6)
- Philosophy of Cognitive Science (30)
- Animal Cognition (1)
- Connectionism and Eliminativism (1)
- Dementia (1)
- Evolutionary Psychology (1)
- Introspection and Introspectionism (2)
- Neurophilosophy (2)
- Other Mental Disorders (1)
- Philosophy of Neuroscience (2)
- Philosophy of Psychiatry and Psychopathology (2)
- Philosophy of Psychology (3)
- Psychological Explanation (1)
- Psychopathy (1)
- Representation in Cognitive Science (3)
- Representation in Neuroscience (1)
- The Nature of Folk Psychology (1)
- The Turing Test (1)
- Theory of Mind and Folk Psychology (3)
- Philosophy of Mathematics (10)
- Philosophy of Medicine (2)
- Philosophy of Physical Science (10)
- Bohmian Interpretation (1)
- Classical Mechanics (1)
- Collapse Interpretations (1)
- Copenhagen Interpretation (1)
- Everett Interpretation (1)
- Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (2)
- Measurement Problem (1)
- Philosophy of Cosmology (2)
- Philosophy of Physics (2)
- Quantum Field Theory (1)
- Symmetry in Physics (1)
- Why is there Something? (1)
- Philosophy of Probability (11)
- Philosophy of Social Science (14)
- General Philosophy of Science (61)
- History of Western Philosophy (46)
- 17th/18th Century Philosophy (23)
- Anne Conway (1)
- Cambridge Platonism (1)
- Catharine Trotter Cockburn (1)
- Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1)
- Hobbes: Social Contract (1)
- Hume: Aesthetics (1)
- Hume: Metaphysics and Epistemology (1)
- Hume: Value Theory (3)
- Isaac Newton (1)
- Kant: Aesthetic Judgment (1)
- Kant: Ethics (1)
- Kant: Perception (1)
- Kant: Philosophy of Science, Logic and Mathematics (2)
- Kant: Science (2)
- Locke: Metaphysics (1)
- Locke: Philosophy of Science (1)
- Margaret Cavendish (2)
- Mary Astell (3)
- Princess Elizabeth (4)
- René Descartes (5)
- 19th Century Philosophy (3)
- Hegel (1)
- Josiah Royce (1)
- Nietzsche: Value Theory (1)
- 20th Century Philosophy (11)
- Bertrand Russell (1)
- G. E. Moore (1)
- John Rawls (1)
- Kuki Shūzō (1)
- Ludwig Wittgenstein (2)
- Saul Kripke (1)
- Thomas Kuhn (1)
- W. V. O. Quine (2)
- Wilfrid Sellars (1)
- Ancient Greek and Roman Philosophy (6)
- Aristotle (2)
- Plato (2)
- Plato: Eros (2)
- Plato: Ethics (1)
- Plato: Mathematics (1)
- Stoics (1)
- Medieval and Renaissance Philosophy (4)
- Anselm (1)
- Medieval Philosophy of Language (1)
- Medieval Theology (1)
- Pre-1000 Medieval Philosophy (1)
- Thomas Aquinas (1)
- 17th/18th Century Philosophy (23)
- Philosophical Traditions (39)
- African/Africana Philosophy (6)
- Asian Philosophy (25)
- Chinese Aesthetics (7)
- Chinese Buddhist Philosophy (1)
- Chinese Philosophy (1)
- Chinese Philosophy of Science (1)
- Classical Chinese Philosophy (1)
- Classical Daoism (1)
- Confucius (2)
- Indian Aesthetics (6)
- Indian Logic (1)
- Indian Philosophy (2)
- Japanese Aesthetics (5)
- Korean Aesthetics (1)
- Continental Philosophy (7)
- Continental Feminism (2)
- Judith Butler (1)
- Critical Theory (1)
- Julia Kristeva (1)
- Michel Foucault (1)
- Phenomenology (1)
- Continental Feminism (2)
- Philosophy of the Americas (1)
- Miscellaneous (7)
Keywords
abortion
action
aesthetics
art
art classification
autonomy
causation
cultural property
culture
depiction
desire
disability
distributive justice
education
epistemology
ethics
feminism
fiction
gender
imagination
intuition
justice
Kant
knowledge
logic
metaphysics
mind
models
philosophy of language
philosophy of mathematics
philosophy of mind
philosophy of religion
philosophy of science
portrait
problem of evil
race
Rawls
realism
representation
responsibility
science
truth
value
virtue
virtue ethics