Keyword: endurance
FiltersNEW

Hold ctrl / ⌘ to select more or unselect / Info

Topics

Languages

Traditions

Times (use negative numbers for BCE)

-

Medium:

Recommended use:

Difficulty:


Full textRead free
Haslanger, Sally. Persistence Through Time
2003, In Michael J. Loux & Dean W. Zimmerman (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Metaphysics. Oxford University Press, 315-354.

Expand entry

Added by: Nick Novelli
Introduction: Things change: objects come into existence, last for a while, go out of existence, move through space, change their parts, change their qualities, change in their relations to things. All this would seem to be uncontroversial. But philosophical attention to any of these phenomena can generate perplexity and has resulted in a number of long-standing puzzles. One of the most famous puzzles about change threatens to demonstrate that nothing can persist through time, that all existence is momentary at best. Let's use the term 'alteration' for the sort of change that occurs when a persisting object changes its properties.
Comment: A good overview of the philosophical issues involved in persistence through time. Would be a good preliminary material in a philosophy of time course. Or, since this is a fundamental philosophical problem, could be used in an introduction to philosophy course as a more clear alternative or supplement to ancient sources.
Full text
Hawley, Katherine. Sameness and Difference
2001, In Hawley, K., How Things Persist. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Expand entry
Added by: Clotilde Torregrossa
Abstract:

In the center of stability is how things persist amidst varying state of changes from the casual process of daily routine and endurance of an object specifically explained in the example of a book still intact despite being spilled by coffee. This chapter considers the philosopher David Lewis's attack on properties as relations to times in his book ‘On the Plurality of Worlds’. Temporary processing of features is considered a phase on the ideal and it only shows that people change just as materials due over the course of time by refecting on an individual's differing state of mind in different moments. The immateriality of people accounts for the inescapable changes and theories of persistence may have something to do with the decision to change.

Comment: The first part of this chapter provides some background on the distinction between endurantism and perdurantism, and as such could be used an introductory class on the metaphysics of identity and change. However, the rest of the chapter develops a more technical argument against Lewis' objections to the view that properties are relations to times, and that instead properties such as shape are obviously intrinsic. As such, this text could be read alongside excerpts from Lewis' On the Plurality of Worlds. It can also be read for its defence of adverbialism, in a more advanced seminar.
Can’t find it?
Contribute the texts you think should be here and we’ll add them soon!