Shun, Kwong-loi. Studying Confucian and Comparative Ethics: Methodological Reflections
2009, Shun, K.-l. 'Studying Confucian and Comparative Ethics: Methodological Reflections', Journal of Chinese Philosophy 36(3), pp. 455–478
Added by: Lea Cantor, Contributed by: Lea Cantor
Abstract:
Comment: This article reflects on the challenges that arise in the study and practice of comparative philosophy, focusing on the case of 'Western'-Chinese comparative work in ethics. The paper more specifically highlights an 'asymmetry' worry in relation to much existing comparative engagement with Chinese ethics, whereby the frameworks of 'Western Philosophy' are taken as the unquestioned reference point by which to analyse (unilaterally) Chinese ethics. The paper will be easy to follow for those with a basic understanding of Chinese philosophy (especially (neo-)Confucian ethics) and some understanding of contemporary debates in normative ethics and moral philosophy. It could easily be integrated into courses on normative ethics and moral philosophy, Chinese philosophy, and/or comparative philosophy.